Skip to main content

Remove Your Media

Blog Details

  • Home
  • DNS Site-Blocking: Rights Holders Go Around Courts

DNS Site-Blocking: Rights Holders Go Around Courts

A quiet but significant shift is reshaping the global fight against digital piracy. Rather than waiting months or years for court-ordered site-blocking injunctions, major rights holders are increasingly negotiating directly with DNS resolver operators — most notably Google Public DNS and Cloudflare — to block access to infringing websites at the infrastructure level. This emerging strategy represents one of the most consequential developments in copyright enforcement in over a decade, offering faster, scalable protection without the jurisdictional friction that has long plagued traditional legal routes. For entertainment brands, music labels, anime distributors, and sports leagues fighting daily battles against piracy, understanding how DNS-based blocking works — and how to leverage it — is no longer optional.

What Is DNS-Level Site Blocking and Why Does It Matter?

The Domain Name System, or DNS, functions as the internet’s phonebook. When a user types a web address into their browser, a DNS resolver translates that human-readable domain name into an IP address that routes the user to the correct server. Most internet users rely on either their ISP’s default resolver, Google’s Public DNS (8.8.8.8), or Cloudflare’s resolver (1.1.1.1) — three services that together handle an enormous share of global DNS queries.

DNS-level blocking works by instructing a resolver to return a null response or redirect for a specific domain, effectively making that site unreachable for users relying on that resolver. Unlike IP-blocking or URL-level filtering, DNS blocking is straightforward to implement, applies globally rather than in a single jurisdiction, and can be updated rapidly as piracy operators shift domains.

What makes this development particularly noteworthy is the shift in who initiates it. Historically, site blocking was the domain of courts — rights holders would petition judges in countries like the UK, Australia, or Germany for blocking injunctions that ISPs were legally compelled to enforce. Now, rights holders and their enforcement partners are exploring whether they can achieve similar outcomes through direct agreements with DNS providers, bypassing the courts entirely.

The Traditional Court-Order Model and Its Limitations

For years, court-ordered site blocking has been the gold standard of anti-piracy enforcement in jurisdictions that permit it. The United Kingdom’s Piracy Site Blocking regime, Australia’s Federal Court injunction system, and similar frameworks across Europe and Asia-Pacific have collectively resulted in thousands of domains being blocked at the ISP level. These systems work — studies consistently show meaningful reductions in piracy traffic following blocking orders.

But the model has serious limitations. Obtaining a blocking injunction typically requires initiating litigation, demonstrating that a target site is primarily used for infringement, and satisfying procedural requirements that vary by jurisdiction. This process can take anywhere from several months to several years. Legal costs are substantial, and enforcement must often be repeated as operators pivot to mirror domains or new URLs.

Perhaps most frustrating for rights holders is jurisdictional fragmentation. A blocking order obtained in the UK does nothing for users in the United States, Canada, or Southeast Asia. Rights holders protecting global IP — think major anime publishers, K-pop labels, NBA broadcast rights holders — face the Sisyphean task of filing in dozens of jurisdictions simultaneously, each with different legal standards and timelines.

It is precisely these limitations that have driven interest in a more direct approach: negotiating with the companies that control the DNS infrastructure millions of people use every day.

How Voluntary DNS Resolver Agreements Work

The mechanics of voluntary DNS resolver agreements are still evolving, and the deals that have been reached are rarely publicized in granular detail. However, the general framework involves rights holder coalitions — or their authorized enforcement agents — providing DNS operators with verified lists of infringing domains. The resolver operator then applies blocking or filtering to those domains for users who rely on their service.

In some models, blocking is applied automatically when a domain appears on a trusted blocklist maintained by an industry body. In others, there is a review process in which the DNS operator evaluates the claim before applying any filter. The key distinction from court-ordered blocking is that participation is voluntary on the part of the resolver operator. They are not legally compelled to act — they choose to do so as part of a broader commitment to trust and safety, or in some cases as part of a commercial or reputational arrangement with the entertainment industry.

Cloudflare has been particularly active in this space, having faced significant pressure from rights holders following several high-profile cases. The company’s public statements have acknowledged a growing willingness to work with rights holders outside of formal legal processes, though it has also been careful to define limits on what it will do voluntarily versus what requires legal compulsion. Google’s position on its Public DNS resolver has been similarly nuanced, with the company navigating tensions between its role as an infrastructure provider and the policy positions it has historically taken on internet openness.

The Role of Industry Coalitions and Trusted Notifier Programs

One of the most important enablers of voluntary DNS blocking is the rise of trusted notifier programs. Rather than requiring individual rights holders to negotiate one-on-one with DNS providers, these programs designate certain organizations — typically industry coalitions or well-established enforcement agencies — as trusted sources of infringement data. When a trusted notifier submits a domain for blocking, the DNS provider can act with greater confidence that the claim is accurate and legally sound.

In the music industry, bodies like the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) and the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) have long-standing relationships with platforms and infrastructure providers that give them elevated credibility in enforcement conversations. Similar dynamics apply in film and television, where the Motion Picture Association (MPA) has been at the forefront of global site-blocking advocacy.

For sports rights holders like NBA Properties, and for anime and entertainment companies like Crunchyroll and VIZ Media, the pathway to participation in trusted notifier frameworks often runs through enforcement partners who have already established these relationships. This is one of the most practical reasons why working with a specialized anti-piracy firm — rather than pursuing enforcement in-house — provides a meaningful strategic advantage.

Trusted notifier status is not handed out freely. DNS providers require demonstrated accuracy, legal accountability, and operational transparency from organizations they designate as trusted sources. Building and maintaining that status is itself a form of competitive advantage in the enforcement ecosystem.

Legal and Policy Tensions Surrounding Voluntary Blocking

Voluntary DNS blocking is not without controversy, and rights holders pursuing this strategy should be aware of the legal and policy debates that surround it. Critics — including digital rights organizations, academic researchers, and some internet governance bodies — argue that voluntary infrastructure-level blocking raises serious concerns about due process, over-blocking, and the privatization of internet censorship.

The due process concern is straightforward: when a court orders a site blocked, there is a judicial record, an opportunity for the blocked party to contest the order, and a defined legal standard that must be met. Voluntary blocking by a private company involves none of these safeguards. A domain operator who believes their site has been wrongly blocked may have limited recourse, particularly if they are based in a jurisdiction with limited legal resources.

Over-blocking is a related concern. DNS blocking operates at the domain level, which means that an entire domain is blocked rather than specific infringing URLs. If a piracy site shares infrastructure with legitimate services — or if a domain has both infringing and non-infringing content — blocking it entirely may sweep up lawful speech. Rights holders and their enforcement partners have strong incentives to maintain accuracy, but mistakes happen, and the consequences can be significant.

These tensions do not make DNS resolver agreements the wrong tool. They do mean that rights holders and enforcement partners must approach this strategy with precision, strong verification processes, and a clear understanding of where the legal and reputational lines are drawn.

What This Means for Entertainment and Sports Rights Holders

For the kinds of clients Remove Your Media represents — major sports leagues, global music labels, anime streaming platforms, and entertainment conglomerates — the implications of this shift are profound. Piracy is not a static threat. Sites that are taken down via DMCA notices reappear under new domains within hours. Cyberlockers, stream-ripping services, and illicit IPTV providers have become sophisticated operators capable of rapid adaptation.

DNS-level blocking, when implemented effectively and at scale, creates a different kind of friction for these operators. Unlike a single DMCA takedown, which addresses one URL at a time, DNS blocking can neutralize an entire domain for millions of users simultaneously. And because major resolvers like Google and Cloudflare are global services, a single agreement can have enforcement effects across multiple continents.

For K-pop labels like HYBE — which manages artists including BTS, NewJeans, ENHYPEN, and LE SSERAFIM — the unauthorized distribution of music, music videos, and fan content represents both a revenue and a brand integrity issue. Fans who encounter pirated content may not realize they are receiving lower-quality files or supporting operators who profit from the artists they love. DNS blocking can intercept that harm before it reaches the end user.

Similarly, for anime rights holders like Crunchyroll and VIZ Media, the proliferation of unauthorized streaming sites has long undermined legitimate subscription models. Every viewer who watches on a piracy site instead of a licensed platform is a lost subscriber. DNS-level intervention, particularly when combined with robust DMCA enforcement and domain seizure strategies, can meaningfully shift those numbers.

Practical Considerations for Rights Holders Exploring This Strategy

Rights holders interested in pursuing DNS resolver agreements as part of a broader anti-piracy strategy should consider several practical realities before moving forward.

First, DNS blocking is most effective as part of a layered enforcement approach, not as a standalone solution. Piracy operators frequently use dynamic DNS services, content delivery networks, and rapidly rotating domains to evade single-vector enforcement. DNS blocking should be combined with DMCA takedown campaigns, hosting provider notifications, domain registrar enforcement, and where appropriate, litigation.

Second, the quality of the target list matters enormously. Submitting inaccurate or overbroad domain lists to DNS providers — even voluntarily — can damage credibility with those providers and expose rights holders to legal risk. Effective enforcement requires robust site categorization, evidence collection, and ongoing monitoring to ensure that blocked domains remain infringing and that new infringing domains are identified promptly.

Third, engagement with DNS providers is a relationship, not a transaction. Building the kind of trust that allows for rapid response when new infringing sites emerge requires ongoing communication, demonstrated accuracy, and a willingness to engage in good-faith dialogue about edge cases and policy concerns. This is not work that can be done effectively on a one-off basis — it requires sustained, professional engagement over time.

The Future of Infrastructure-Level Copyright Enforcement

DNS resolver agreements represent the leading edge of a broader trend toward infrastructure-level copyright enforcement. As piracy operators have become more sophisticated, rights holders and their enforcement partners have recognized that addressing infringement at the application layer — individual URLs and files — is insufficient on its own. The frontier of enforcement is increasingly at the infrastructure layer: DNS, hosting, CDN, domain registration, and payment processing.

Regulatory pressure is accelerating this trend. The European Union’s Digital Services Act creates new accountability frameworks for large online platforms and infrastructure providers that will likely increase their willingness to engage in voluntary enforcement agreements. Similar legislative developments are underway in the UK, Australia, and several Asian markets.

The rights holders who will be best positioned in this environment are those who have invested in building trusted relationships with infrastructure providers now — before regulatory frameworks crystallize and before piracy operators adapt to new enforcement vectors. Early movers in DNS resolver enforcement are establishing precedents and relationships that will provide durable competitive advantages in the years ahead.

The internet’s infrastructure was not designed with copyright enforcement in mind, but it is increasingly being shaped by it. For rights holders willing to engage seriously with this new reality, the opportunities for more effective, scalable, and global protection of their content are significant.

Partner with Remove Your Media to Navigate DNS Enforcement

At Remove Your Media LLC, we work at the intersection of legal expertise, technical capability, and industry relationships to deliver comprehensive anti-piracy enforcement for some of the world’s most prominent entertainment brands. Whether your priority is DMCA takedowns, hosting provider enforcement, domain seizure, or emerging strategies like DNS resolver engagement, our team has the experience and connections to move quickly and effectively on your behalf.

If your content is being pirated and you want to understand how infrastructure-level enforcement strategies can be integrated into your broader protection program, we want to hear from you. Our team is ready to assess your situation and recommend a tailored enforcement approach designed to deliver measurable results.

Contact Remove Your Media LLC today to speak with an anti-piracy specialist and take the next step in protecting what you’ve created.

Authoritative Sources & Further Reading

Remove Your Media
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.