Live-event piracy enforcement is moving faster than at any point in the past decade, and the next European Commission move could set the global benchmark for takedowns at live speed. Industry groups are pressing Brussels for a binding approach to sports and live-event piracy. A French court fight over DNS blocking is about to reach a flashpoint. For rightsholders, broadcasters and platforms, this is the moment to understand what a real-time anti-piracy regime requires, and what it risks.
What Is New This Week
The Audiovisual Anti-Piracy Alliance (AAPA) issued a plea on November 17, 2026 for a three-layered approach to site blocking, ahead of recommendations the European Commission is expected to issue “in November.” Trade coverage on November 20 summarized the plan in three parts. Hosts would remove pirated live streams within 30 minutes of a valid notice. Repeat offenders would go on an EU-wide register that other providers could not serve. Every member state would need a blocking system that can add new targets during a live event.
As of today, November 21, we have not seen a new Commission Recommendation published, so the details remain proposals and expectations rather than settled policy. The timing still matters. The Council is also discussing the issue. A Presidency paper asks Member States what further EU-level action they would find useful against piracy of live or time-sensitive content. The paper notes that the Commission is exploring this as part of a potential copyright initiative.
Why the 2023 Recommendation Fell Short
To see why a second attempt is being discussed, start with the first. In May 2023 the Commission adopted a Recommendation on combating online piracy of sports and other live events. It was non-binding by design. The Commission’s own review, published on November 20, 2025, was candid about the results. Because the Recommendation is non-binding, its effects were limited and did not significantly curb the volume of live-event piracy.
The assessment was not all negative. The Commission said the Recommendation had contributed to advancing efforts to combat live-event piracy. The problem was persistence. There was overall stagnant web-based piracy alongside piracy through illegal IPTV. On speed, the weak point for live content, the assessment found limited improvement in how promptly notices relating to live events were handled.

The Live Content Coalition, which represents broadcasters, sports bodies and live content producers, drew a firm conclusion. It argued that legislation is needed to clarify what “expeditious” removal actually means. That single word sits at the center of the debate.
The 30-Minute Question
Why does the clock matter so much? A live match, concert or fight has most of its commercial value while it is happening. A takedown that lands the next morning protects almost nothing. The Commission’s 2023 approach asked hosting services to process notices as quickly as possible, but the review found only limited progress against that goal.
A July 2026 European Parliament study pushed for specificity. It suggested compliance timeframes suited to the live context, with a maximum limit such as 30 minutes, as in Italy’s Piracy Shield. It also called for metrics on the speed and effectiveness of enforcement. The study described live-content piracy as a structured and economically resilient segment of the piracy ecosystem, especially in sports broadcasting.
Not everyone treats a fixed number as a cure. Commentary on the AAPA proposal cautioned that a 30-minute blocking requirement is well-intentioned, but blocking needs nuance and fine-tuning so the wrong parties are not blocked. A hard deadline helps only if the notices behind it are accurate and the process has safeguards.

France Shows Where Real-Time Blocking Is Heading
France is the clearest test case for dynamic, real-time enforcement. Its sports code lets rightsholders obtain dynamic blocking orders that cover identified sites and new mirror domains notified later through Arcom, against any person able to help stop the infringement. In July 2026, Parliament passed Law 2026-725 on professional sport, which amended that provision and added an automated real-time blocking system run by Arcom.
The orders have reached beyond access providers. Fourteen new orders for the 2026/27 football season target ISPs, Google, Quad9, DNS4EU, Cloudflare, VPNs and Bing. In a January ruling on VPN blocking, the Paris court rejected the idea that such measures amount to a general monitoring obligation barred under the DSA, because they were limited to specific domains and ended after the season.
The Quad9 Exit: A Warning for Policymakers
The French approach now has a visible cost. Free DNS resolver Quad9 will stop serving France on Tuesday, November 24, after a Paris court ruled against it in a blocking case brought by a broadcaster. The Swiss nonprofit says limiting the block to French users alone is technically out of reach, so leaving was the remaining choice. An appeal is pending, but the exit goes ahead whatever its outcome.

The penalty at issue was modest. The court set a €1,000 daily penalty, far below the amount the broadcaster sought. The episode shows that enforcement orders aimed at infrastructure providers can produce unintended consequences. Any EU framework that extends obligations to DNS resolvers, CDNs and VPNs will have to address how orders apply across borders. It will also need to account for services that decline to comply rather than adapt.
How Takedown Law Works at Live Speed
In the EU, the Digital Services Act is the foundation. The 2023 Recommendation clarified that the DSA applies to live-content piracy and that infringements can be notified. The DSA’s notice-and-action rules require hosting services to act on well-founded notices. Its trusted flagger mechanism gives priority handling to notices from vetted entities. Injunctions against intermediaries rest on a separate foundation. They are based on Article 8(3) of the InfoSoc Directive.
In the United States, the DMCA’s safe harbor for hosting providers is conditioned on acting expeditiously to remove infringing material once they receive a compliant notice. The statute sets no number of minutes, and that vagueness is the same gap Brussels is now debating. Congress has also taken an interest in blocking. Reports say two site-blocking bills were introduced in September, which would let courts order companies to block foreign pirate sites, including live sports streams. We will watch how those proposals develop.

A Practical Playbook for Live-Event Rightsholders
Whatever Brussels decides, the fundamentals of live enforcement are already clear. Here is what experienced rightsholders and enforcement professionals prepare.
- Documented rights before the event. Notices move fastest when the chain of title, territory and event schedule are already assembled and accurate.
- Complete, valid notices. A notice that meets DMCA or DSA requirements is harder to refuse or delay. An incomplete one wastes minutes you do not have.
- Escalation planning. A single removal rarely ends a live-event problem, because pirate operators relaunch streams quickly. Effective programs plan for repeat activity and escalate through every available avenue, with no guarantee that any given stream will come down.
- Court-ready evidence. Where dynamic injunctions exist, a clear record of infringement supports applications and updates.
- Post-event follow-through. Repeat-infringer records and cleanup of re-uploads and clips protect the value of the library after the final whistle.
Speed is only part of the answer. The same live-speed discipline also applies to concerts, premieres, esports and other time-sensitive broadcasts, not just top-tier sports.
Accuracy and Safeguards Are Part of Speed
Faster enforcement raises the cost of mistakes. A recent report from India shows the risk. Two forged court orders persuaded India’s telecom department to issue nationwide blocking instructions. That case involved betting sites rather than live sports, but it shows why verification matters when orders flow quickly through intermediaries. Real-time systems need ways to authenticate orders and notices, correct errors fast and reverse blocks when they are wrong.
The Commission’s 2023 text already stressed safeguards. It emphasized robust protection of fundamental rights when injunctions are issued against live-event piracy. Expect that balance to feature heavily in the next draft. Proposals that pair fast action with transparency, accuracy requirements and a route to challenge errors are more likely to survive scrutiny.

What to Watch Next
Three things will shape the next few months. The first is whether the Commission publishes a new Recommendation, and whether it sets a numeric deadline or leaves “expeditious” undefined. The second is whether a non-binding instrument is enough. Industry coalitions have already said legislative action is an urgent necessity, so a second Recommendation without binding force may draw criticism. The third is how courts handle infrastructure intermediaries after the Quad9 withdrawal takes effect and the appeal proceeds.
For rightsholders, the practical message is steady. Prepare rights documentation early, send precise notices, and treat live events as a race that is won in minutes rather than days. Remove Your Media LLC will keep following these EU and US developments as live-event piracy enforcement tightens.