Parallel imports and gray market goods represent one of the most complex and commercially significant challenges in global intellectual property enforcement today. For brand owners, entertainment companies, and rights holders operating across multiple jurisdictions, understanding how trademark exhaustion doctrines differ between the United States, the European Union, and the Asia-Pacific region is not merely an academic exercise — it is a critical business imperative. Misjudging which exhaustion standard applies in a given market can mean the difference between successful enforcement and a costly legal defeat, opening the door to unauthorized distribution channels that erode brand value and consumer trust.
What Are Parallel Imports and Gray Market Goods?
Before diving into jurisdictional differences, it is essential to define the core concepts. A parallel import is a genuine, non-counterfeit product that is manufactured by or under license from the trademark owner in one country and then imported into another country without the trademark holder’s authorization for that specific market. These products are sometimes called gray market goods to distinguish them from outright counterfeits, which are fake products bearing unauthorized copies of a trademark.
The distinction matters enormously. Gray market goods are authentic — they carry a real trademark applied by or with the consent of the rights holder somewhere in the world. The legal question is whether that initial authorized sale “exhausts” the trademark owner’s rights to control further distribution in every other market, or whether the rights holder retains the power to restrict importation into specific territories.
For entertainment brands in particular — think licensed merchandise, physical media, collectibles, and K-pop albums — the gray market can be especially disruptive. Products licensed for sale in Japan, for instance, may flood the U.S. market at prices that undercut authorized domestic retailers, damaging distribution agreements and reducing royalties owed to rights holders.
The Doctrine of Trademark Exhaustion Explained
Trademark exhaustion — also called the “first sale doctrine” in the United States — is a legal principle that limits how long a trademark owner can control the downstream distribution of a product after its initial authorized sale. Once a rights holder sells a trademarked good, they generally cannot use trademark law to prevent the buyer from reselling that product. The key legal battleground is how far that exhaustion extends geographically.
There are three recognized models of trademark exhaustion used around the world:
- National Exhaustion: Rights are exhausted only within the country where the first authorized sale took place. Importation of the same product from another country still requires the trademark owner’s consent.
- Regional Exhaustion: Rights are exhausted across a defined group of countries (such as the EU member states) once a product is placed on the market anywhere within that region.
- International Exhaustion: Rights are exhausted globally upon any first authorized sale anywhere in the world, meaning the trademark owner cannot prevent importation from any country.
Each model produces dramatically different outcomes for rights holders, distributors, and consumers — and different countries have adopted different standards, sometimes with important nuances layered on top.

The United States: National Exhaustion With Important Exceptions
The United States generally follows a national exhaustion model under the Lanham Act, meaning that a trademark owner’s authorization of a sale outside the U.S. does not automatically exhaust their rights in the American market. This provides significant protection for brand owners who enter into exclusive territorial distribution agreements.
The landmark case here is Lever Brothers Co. v. United States (D.C. Circuit, 1993), which held that the U.S. Customs Service was required to bar importation of foreign-made Lever Brothers products that, while genuine, differed materially from their American counterparts. The “material differences” standard became central to U.S. gray market law — if an imported product differs in any material way from the version authorized for sale domestically, the trademark owner can block its importation.
What counts as a material difference? Courts have interpreted this broadly to include differences in formulation, labeling, language, warranty terms, customer support availability, and even packaging size. For entertainment and consumer goods brands, this often means that products licensed for a foreign market — with region-specific packaging, local-language inserts, or different content ratings — can be stopped at the U.S. border.
However, the U.S. Copyright Office’s Section 109 first sale doctrine under copyright law adds a layer of complexity. In Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons (2013), the Supreme Court held that the copyright first sale doctrine applies internationally, meaning that lawfully made copies of copyrighted works purchased abroad can be resold in the U.S. without the copyright holder’s permission. This creates a notable tension between U.S. trademark law (which tends toward national exhaustion) and U.S. copyright law (which effectively adopts international exhaustion for resale purposes).
The European Union: Regional Exhaustion and Consent-Based Controls
The European Union operates under a regional exhaustion model established by the EU Trademark Directive and the Trade Mark Regulation. Once a trademarked product is placed on the market anywhere within the European Economic Area (EEA) — which includes the EU member states plus Norway, Iceland, and Liechtenstein — by the trademark owner or with their consent, the trademark is exhausted throughout the entire EEA.

This means a brand owner cannot use trademark rights to prevent a product sold in Germany from being resold in France or Spain. The policy goal is to support the EU’s fundamental principle of the free movement of goods across the single market. For large consumer brands with pan-European distribution, this is a well-understood operating reality.
Critically, however, the EU does not recognize international exhaustion. Products placed on the market outside the EEA — in the United States, Japan, or South Korea, for example — do not trigger exhaustion of EU trademark rights. Brand owners can and regularly do obtain injunctions blocking importation of goods from outside the EEA, even when those goods are authentic and were manufactured by the very same rights holder.
The consent element is also highly litigated in EU courts. The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has ruled that consent must be expressed or clearly implied — and that a trademark owner’s simple failure to object to earlier imports does not constitute consent for future parallel imports. Rights holders must be proactive and explicit in structuring their distribution contracts to avoid inadvertently consenting to parallel trade.
Asia-Pacific: A Patchwork of National Standards
The Asia-Pacific region presents no single unified exhaustion standard. Instead, brands face a genuinely diverse patchwork of national laws, with significant practical and strategic implications for rights holders operating across multiple APAC markets.
Japan has adopted a form of international exhaustion through its Supreme Court decision in the BBS Kraftfahrzeugtechnik case (1997), which held that parallel imports of genuine goods are generally permissible unless the trademark owner has explicitly communicated to buyers that the goods are not authorized for import into Japan. Japanese law also permits parallel imports of trademarked goods that do not materially differ from their domestically authorized equivalents — a standard similar in spirit to U.S. material differences doctrine, but applied within an international exhaustion framework.

South Korea is particularly relevant for entertainment industry rights holders given the global reach of K-pop and Korean entertainment content. Korea generally permits parallel imports of genuine goods but restricts them where the imported product differs materially from the domestic version or where importation would damage the trademark’s quality control function. For HYBE labels and similar entertainment companies with complex domestic and international licensing structures, maintaining clear quality differentiation between regional product lines is an important enforcement tool.
China presents unique challenges. While Chinese law does not formally adopt a single exhaustion standard by statute, courts have generally leaned toward permitting parallel imports of genuine goods, viewing them as beneficial to consumer access and competitive pricing. However, enforcement actions can still succeed where quality differences exist or where false impressions about authorization are created. Brand owners in China must rely heavily on contractual protections, customs recordation, and active monitoring rather than exclusive reliance on trademark exhaustion arguments.
Australia notably amended its Trade Marks Act in 1995 to effectively adopt international exhaustion, permitting parallel imports of genuine goods unless importation involves conduct beyond mere resale that would be misleading. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has actively supported parallel import regimes as pro-competitive policy.
Strategic Implications for Entertainment Rights Holders
For entertainment companies with global licensing portfolios — including those managing anime merchandise, K-pop physical media, sports memorabilia, and licensed apparel — the divergence in exhaustion doctrines creates both risks and strategic opportunities.
The most important practical implication is the value of intentional product differentiation. By ensuring that products authorized for different regional markets carry meaningful differences — different packaging, region-specific content, warranty terms, or language variations — rights holders strengthen their ability to invoke material differences arguments in national exhaustion or qualified international exhaustion jurisdictions. This requires close coordination between licensing, product development, and legal teams from the earliest stages of product design.

Distribution contract drafting is equally critical. Exclusive distribution agreements should include explicit prohibitions on authorized distributors supplying gray market channels outside their licensed territory. These contractual controls do not change the underlying exhaustion doctrine, but they create breach of contract remedies and can support arguments that any downstream sale into a restricted market lacked the rights holder’s genuine consent.
Customs recordation programs in the U.S. (with U.S. Customs and Border Protection), the EU, and several APAC jurisdictions allow rights holders to register trademarks and copyrights to enable border enforcement against infringing and gray market shipments. These programs are significantly underutilized by entertainment brands and represent a high-return enforcement investment relative to their cost.
The Intersection of Copyright and Trademark in Gray Market Enforcement
Gray market enforcement is rarely a pure trademark question. For entertainment goods — which are almost always bundled with copyrighted content, artwork, or creative elements — copyright law runs alongside trademark law and can either strengthen or complicate the enforcement picture.
In the United States, as noted above, the Kirtsaeng decision limits the ability to use copyright law to block resale of lawfully purchased foreign copies, even though trademark law may still provide a route to border enforcement for materially different goods. Rights holders must carefully analyze both the trademark and copyright dimensions of any gray market enforcement strategy to identify which legal tools are available and which are foreclosed by doctrine.
In the EU, the Software and Database Directives have introduced specific exhaustion rules for digital content that differ from physical goods rules — an increasingly important issue as entertainment distribution blurs the line between physical and digital products. These nuances require jurisdiction-specific legal analysis rather than blanket global strategies.

Working With Experienced IP Enforcement Partners
Navigating parallel import and gray market issues across the U.S., EU, and Asia-Pacific requires deep expertise in both the legal doctrine and the practical enforcement mechanisms available in each market. Rights holders who attempt to apply a one-size-fits-all approach often find that strategies effective in their home jurisdiction fail entirely abroad — or, worse, expose them to antitrust liability for improperly restricting legitimate trade.
Effective gray market enforcement requires coordinated action across customs recordation, marketplace monitoring, distributor compliance programs, and strategic litigation — all tailored to the specific exhaustion regime of each target jurisdiction. It also demands ongoing vigilance, because gray market channels evolve quickly in response to enforcement pressure, migrating across platforms and jurisdictions to exploit gaps in coverage.
Entertainment brands are particularly vulnerable to gray market erosion because their products carry strong consumer demand globally, creating powerful economic incentives for unauthorized importers. The same brand strength that drives fan enthusiasm also drives the gray market — which is why proactive, expert enforcement is not optional but essential for protecting long-term brand equity and licensee relationships.
At Remove Your Media LLC, we work with entertainment rights holders, sports organizations, music labels, and consumer brands to build comprehensive IP enforcement programs that address parallel import risks alongside traditional piracy and counterfeiting threats. Our team understands the nuanced differences between exhaustion doctrines across key global markets and can help you design enforcement strategies that hold up across jurisdictions. If gray market goods or parallel imports are affecting your brand’s market integrity, contact us today to discuss how we can help protect your rights at every stage of the distribution chain.
Authoritative Sources & Further Reading
- 15 U.S.C. § 1124 – Importation of Goods Bearing Infringing Marks (LII) — Primary U.S. statutory authority governing the exclusion of gray market goods bearing infringing or counterfeit trademarks at the border.
- EU Trade Mark Regulation (EUTMR) No. 2017/1001 – EUR-Lex — The governing EU regulation codifying regional trademark exhaustion, the legal foundation for parallel import rules across EU member states.
- K Mart Corp. v. Cartier, Inc., 486 U.S. 281 (1988) – FindLaw — Landmark U.S. Supreme Court ruling directly addressing gray market goods and the limits of trademark protection against authorized parallel imports.
- WTO TRIPS Agreement – Full Text — Article 6 of TRIPS explicitly permits member states to set their own exhaustion policies, making it the foundational international treaty for this topic.