Skip to main content

Remove Your Media

Blog Details

  • Home
  • The Marrakesh Treaty in Practice: Balancing Access and Enforcement for Rights Holders

The Marrakesh Treaty in Practice: Balancing Access and Enforcement for Rights Holders

The Marrakesh Treaty to Facilitate Access to Published Works for Persons Who Are Blind, Visually Impaired, or Otherwise Print Disabled represents one of the most significant humanitarian milestones in international copyright law. Yet for rights holders, entertainment companies, and copyright enforcement professionals, this landmark WIPO agreement introduces a nuanced set of challenges that demand careful navigation. Understanding how the Marrakesh Treaty operates in practice — and how it intersects with robust anti-piracy enforcement — is essential for any organization serious about protecting intellectual property while honoring legitimate access obligations in today’s global digital marketplace.

What the Marrakesh Treaty Actually Does

Adopted in 2013 and entering into force in 2016, the Marrakesh Treaty establishes a mandatory set of exceptions and limitations to copyright law, specifically designed to facilitate the creation and cross-border sharing of accessible format copies for beneficiary persons. These accessible formats include Braille, audio recordings, large-print editions, and digital formats compatible with screen readers and other assistive technologies.

Under the treaty framework, authorized entities — typically nonprofits, government agencies, or educational institutions serving the visually impaired — are permitted to produce accessible versions of copyrighted works without seeking prior authorization from rights holders, subject to certain conditions. Crucially, the treaty also permits the cross-border exchange of these accessible format copies between authorized entities in member countries, dramatically expanding the global library of materials available to print-disabled individuals.

As of 2024, over 90 countries have ratified the treaty, including the United States, the European Union member states, Japan, and many others. For rights holders operating across multiple jurisdictions — a common reality for entertainment companies like those Remove Your Media represents — this means the Marrakesh framework applies broadly to their catalog of protected works.

Key Obligations and Limitations for Rights Holders

The Marrakesh Treaty does not grant unlimited access to copyrighted content. The framework is carefully bounded by several important safeguards that rights holders should understand:

  • Beneficiary persons are narrowly defined: The treaty covers individuals who are blind, have a visual impairment that cannot be corrected, have a perceptual or reading disability such as dyslexia, or are physically unable to hold or manipulate a book.
  • Only authorized entities may distribute: Random websites or individuals cannot claim Marrakesh protections. Distribution must flow through formally authorized organizations with demonstrated accountability to beneficiary populations.
  • Commercial availability clauses: Some national implementations include provisions that limit the exception when a commercially available accessible format already exists, providing rights holders an opportunity to serve this market directly.
  • No profit motive permitted: Accessible format copies produced under Marrakesh exceptions must be made on a non-commercial basis.
  • Three-step test compliance: Like all WIPO-sanctioned exceptions, Marrakesh limitations must conform to the three-step test — applying only in special cases that do not conflict with normal exploitation of the work and do not unreasonably prejudice the rights holder’s legitimate interests.

Understanding these boundaries is critical. Rights holders are not asked to surrender their copyrights under the Marrakesh framework — they are asked to accept narrowly scoped, socially necessary exceptions with meaningful guardrails in place.

Where Enforcement Challenges Emerge

Despite the treaty’s careful scoping, the Marrakesh framework does create real-world enforcement complexities that copyright protection professionals must take seriously. The most pressing concern is the potential for bad actors to exploit the treaty’s provisions as a shield for unauthorized distribution.

Consider the following scenarios that enforcement teams encounter:

  • Fraudulent “authorized entity” claims: Piracy networks have, in some documented cases, attempted to misrepresent their operations as serving print-disabled communities in order to justify hosting accessible-format files. A robust enforcement program must be able to investigate and challenge these claims.
  • Scope creep in accessible format distribution: An accessible format copy produced legitimately under Marrakesh provisions can be re-shared or redistributed in non-compliant ways once it enters digital circulation. Watermarking and digital rights management strategies become especially important in this context.
  • Cross-border enforcement gaps: The treaty’s cross-border sharing provisions mean that an authorized entity in one jurisdiction may share files with counterparts in another. If monitoring systems aren’t calibrated to account for these legitimate flows, enforcement actions risk targeting compliant actors — a costly and reputationally damaging error.
  • Ambiguity in national implementations: Because the treaty leaves implementation details to member states, the definition of “authorized entity” and the scope of permissible formats varies country by country. A file-sharing activity that is compliant in one jurisdiction may be infringing in another.

For rights holders managing global catalogs — whether that’s anime content for Crunchyroll, K-pop releases for HYBE, or sports media for NBA Properties — these jurisdictional complexities require sophisticated, geographically aware enforcement strategies.

Best Practices for Rights Holders Navigating Marrakesh Compliance

The good news is that the Marrakesh Treaty and rigorous copyright enforcement are not mutually exclusive. Rights holders can honor their treaty obligations while maintaining a strong anti-piracy posture by following several best practices:

  • Develop proactive accessible format programs: Where commercially viable, rights holders who publish their own accessible formats can invoke the commercial availability exception present in many national laws, reducing the scope of the mandatory exception and maintaining greater control over their works.
  • Establish authorized entity verification protocols: Work with legal counsel to develop a clear process for identifying legitimate authorized entities in your key markets. This allows enforcement teams to whitelist known compliant actors and focus resources on genuine infringers.
  • Implement technical protection measures thoughtfully: Digital rights management systems should be designed with Marrakesh compliance in mind. Many national implementations require that technical protection measure circumvention for accessibility purposes be permitted for authorized entities, and enforcement strategies should account for this.
  • Conduct regular audits of accessible format distribution: Monitoring the legitimate ecosystem for your accessible format content helps identify when compliant copies have migrated into infringing channels, enabling targeted takedown actions that don’t disrupt legitimate access.
  • Engage with WIPO and industry coalitions: Participating in ongoing WIPO discussions and industry working groups allows rights holders to shape the evolving interpretation of Marrakesh provisions and stay ahead of emerging compliance challenges.

The Bigger Picture: Access and Protection Working Together

The Marrakesh Treaty ultimately reflects a broader truth about the modern copyright landscape: meaningful content protection and meaningful content access are both essential social goods, and sophisticated rights holders recognize that honoring legitimate exceptions strengthens — rather than weakens — their overall IP enforcement position. When rights holders are seen as responsible stewards of the public interest, they earn greater credibility and cooperation from regulators, platforms, and courts when pursuing bad actors.

At the same time, the treaty does not ask rights holders to be passive. It asks them to be thoughtful. The organizations that navigate Marrakesh most successfully are those with experienced legal and enforcement partners who understand both the humanitarian intent of the treaty and the real-world exploitation risks it can create.

Navigating international copyright frameworks like the Marrakesh Treaty requires more than legal knowledge — it requires operational expertise, global monitoring capabilities, and a nuanced enforcement philosophy. At Remove Your Media LLC, our team brings all three to every client relationship, helping rights holders protect their content aggressively while maintaining full compliance with international obligations. Whether you represent a content studio, a music label, a sports organization, or a publishing house, we have the tools and the expertise to build an enforcement strategy that works across borders and across legal frameworks. Contact Remove Your Media LLC today to discuss how we can help protect your intellectual property in a complex global landscape.

Remove Your Media
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.