Every weekend across the United States, convention floors fill with vendors selling costumes, prints, accessories, and apparel featuring beloved characters from anime, K-pop, sports, and film franchises. While fan enthusiasm drives enormous cultural energy, a significant portion of that vendor activity crosses a critical legal line — the moment cosplay-inspired goods become commercial products sold for profit without authorization. For rights holders, including major entertainment brands and IP owners, understanding when and how to pursue trademark and copyright claims against monetized convention vendors is not just a legal option — it is an essential part of protecting brand value, licensing revenue, and the integrity of their intellectual property.
The Line Between Fan Expression and Commercial Infringement
Fan creativity has always occupied a nuanced space in copyright law. Cosplay itself — wearing a costume to celebrate a character — is generally regarded as personal expression and is rarely the target of enforcement action. The legal calculus changes dramatically, however, when that creativity transforms into commerce.
When a vendor sets up a booth at a major convention and sells unauthorized prints of copyrighted character artwork, screen-accurate costume replicas bearing trademarked logos, or unlicensed pins and patches featuring a brand’s protected imagery, they have stepped squarely into infringing territory. The “fan” label does not provide commercial cover, and courts have consistently held that the for-profit nature of an activity weighs heavily against any fair use defense.
Rights holders must recognize this distinction clearly: personal cosplay is one thing, but a vendor generating thousands of dollars in weekend revenue from unauthorized reproductions of protected IP is engaging in commercial infringement that directly competes with licensed merchandise programs and harms brand owners in measurable, demonstrable ways.
Copyright Protections That Apply to Character Art and Costumes
Copyright law protects original works of authorship fixed in a tangible medium, and this protection extends broadly across the entertainment industry. Character designs, illustrations, graphic artwork, and even specific costume elements can all qualify as copyrightable subject matter when they reflect sufficient originality. For anime studios like those represented by Crunchyroll or VIZ Media, character art is among the most valuable IP a company owns.
When a convention vendor sells art prints, posters, or stickers reproducing a copyrighted character without authorization, they are engaging in unauthorized reproduction and distribution — two of the exclusive rights granted to copyright holders under 17 U.S.C. § 106. These rights do not evaporate simply because the work is being sold at a fan-focused event rather than a retail chain.
The scope of protection can also extend to sculptural elements embodied in three-dimensional costume pieces, particularly when those designs are sufficiently distinctive and original. Rights holders should work with experienced IP counsel to assess which elements of their character designs carry the strongest copyright protection before initiating enforcement campaigns.

Trademark Rights and the Problem of Unauthorized Logos and Branding
Beyond copyright, trademark law provides another powerful avenue for enforcement against convention vendors. Trademarks protect brand identifiers — names, logos, symbols, and trade dress — that consumers associate with a particular source of goods or services. In the entertainment industry, these marks are often among a company’s most commercially significant assets.
Consider the NBA Properties client portfolio. The NBA’s team logos, wordmarks, and jersey designs are federally registered trademarks. When a vendor sells knockoff jerseys or accessories bearing these marks without a license, they are not just copying art — they are trading on the goodwill and consumer recognition that the NBA has spent decades building. This constitutes trademark infringement under the Lanham Act, and it creates real consumer confusion about whether the goods are officially sanctioned.
Similarly, K-pop entertainment companies like HYBE — home to BTS, NewJeans, ENHYPEN, and LE SSERAFIM — have developed powerful brand identities with globally recognized logos and visual marks. Unauthorized merchandise at conventions exploiting these marks undermines official merchandise programs and diverts revenue from the artists and companies who created those brands.
Trademark enforcement also provides advantages that copyright claims do not. Rights holders can pursue claims based on likelihood of confusion even when the infringing goods are not identical copies, and they can seek remedies including injunctive relief, disgorgement of profits, and statutory damages for counterfeiting under 15 U.S.C. § 1117.
How to Identify and Document Infringing Vendors
Effective enforcement begins with thorough documentation. Before any legal action can be taken, rights holders and their representatives must build a clear evidentiary record establishing what was sold, when, where, and by whom. This is especially important in the convention context, where vendors are often transient — appearing for a weekend and then moving on to the next event.

Documentation strategies should include photographic and video evidence of infringing products displayed for sale, the vendor’s booth setup and any identifying signage, and where possible, purchase of infringing items to preserve as physical evidence. Records of the convention’s official vendor directory, if available, can help establish the vendor’s identity and booth registration.
Rights holders should also monitor online marketplaces and social media accounts associated with known convention vendors, as many operate year-round storefronts on platforms like Etsy, Redbubble, and Instagram. Online activity can often provide corroborating evidence of commercial scale and intent, strengthening any subsequent enforcement action.
Working with a professional anti-piracy and DMCA enforcement firm can significantly streamline this process, as experienced teams know exactly what evidence courts and platforms require and can conduct investigations efficiently across multiple events and online channels simultaneously.
Cease and Desist Letters and Convention-Level Enforcement
For many infringing vendors, a well-drafted cease and desist letter is the first and often most efficient enforcement tool. A cease and desist letter formally notifies the vendor of the rights holder’s IP ownership, identifies the specific infringing products or conduct, demands immediate cessation of the infringing activity, and may demand an accounting of profits derived from unauthorized sales.

In the convention setting, enforcement can also be pursued directly through event organizers. Most major conventions — including San Diego Comic-Con, Anime Expo, and similar large-scale events — have IP policies in their vendor agreements and will act on formal complaints from rights holders. Submitting documented complaints to convention organizers can result in booth shutdowns, vendor bans, and removal of infringing merchandise without the need for immediate litigation.
This approach requires building relationships with convention organizers proactively and ensuring that rights holders have clear IP registration documentation ready to present. The faster a rights holder can respond to discovered infringement during an active event, the more effective the intervention will be.
Online Marketplace Enforcement for Convention-Adjacent Sales
Convention vendors rarely limit their sales to in-person events. The vast majority maintain active online storefronts where they sell the same unauthorized merchandise year-round. This means that an effective enforcement strategy must extend beyond the convention floor and into the digital marketplace ecosystem.
Platforms like Etsy, eBay, Redbubble, Society6, and Amazon Handmade all have notice-and-takedown procedures for IP infringement complaints. Submitting properly documented DMCA takedown notices and trademark infringement reports to these platforms can result in rapid removal of infringing listings and, in cases of repeat infringement, termination of the seller’s account entirely.
For rights holders managing large portfolios of protected IP across multiple platforms, automated monitoring and enforcement workflows are essential. Manual searches are simply too slow and too incomplete to address the volume of unauthorized merchandise that appears online following major conventions. Professional enforcement partners can deploy technology-assisted monitoring to identify and report infringing listings at scale, ensuring comprehensive coverage without exhausting in-house legal resources.

When Litigation Becomes Necessary
While most infringement cases at the convention and small vendor level can be resolved through cease and desist letters and platform takedowns, there are circumstances where litigation becomes appropriate and necessary. High-volume commercial infringers who ignore cease and desist demands, vendors operating sophisticated counterfeit operations across multiple markets, and cases where substantial financial harm has already occurred may all warrant federal court action.
Copyright holders can pursue claims in federal district court seeking actual damages and lost profits, or statutory damages of up to $150,000 per work infringed in cases of willful infringement. Trademark counterfeit cases can yield treble damages and attorney’s fees under the Lanham Act. Courts can also issue preliminary injunctions to halt ongoing infringement while litigation proceeds — a critical remedy when a vendor is actively selling at events.
Litigation also serves an important deterrent function. When rights holders demonstrate through court action that they will aggressively enforce their IP, it sends a signal to the broader vendor community that unauthorized sales carry real legal consequences. This reputational enforcement effect can be as valuable as the damages recovered in any individual case.
Building a Proactive Convention Enforcement Strategy
The most effective approach to protecting IP at conventions is not reactive — waiting until infringement is discovered and then scrambling to respond — but proactive. Rights holders should maintain up-to-date federal registrations for both copyrights and trademarks across their key IP assets, as registered rights provide significantly stronger enforcement tools and access to enhanced damages.
Developing a formal enforcement protocol that covers pre-convention monitoring, on-site documentation procedures, rapid cease and desist deployment, and post-convention online marketplace sweeps ensures that no opportunity for infringement to go unaddressed slips through the cracks. Coordinating this protocol across the internal legal team, outside IP counsel, and a professional enforcement partner creates a layered, comprehensive defense of the brand.

Rights holders should also consider implementing official fan art and merchandise programs that create legal pathways for creator communities to participate in the culture around their IP. When fans and small creators have legitimate options, they are more likely to pursue them — and those who choose to infringe commercially despite those options are much easier to identify and pursue without sympathy from the community.
Protecting Your IP Starts with the Right Partner
Convention vendor infringement is one of the most persistent and underaddressed threats to entertainment IP — but rights holders who take a systematic, well-documented approach to enforcement can protect their brands effectively and recover meaningful remedies against commercial infringers. The key is having the right expertise and infrastructure to act quickly, consistently, and at scale.
At Remove Your Media LLC, we specialize in comprehensive IP enforcement for entertainment brands, content creators, and rights holders across industries. From DMCA takedowns and platform enforcement to cease and desist campaigns and litigation support, our team has the experience and technology to protect your intellectual property wherever infringement occurs — online, at conventions, and everywhere in between. If unauthorized vendors are profiting from your IP, we can help you stop them.
Contact Remove Your Media LLC today to discuss a tailored convention and marketplace enforcement strategy for your brand.
Authoritative Sources & Further Reading
- U.S. Copyright Act (Title 17) — Primary statutory source governing copyright protections applicable to character designs and costumes used in cosplay merchandise.
- USPTO: What Is a Trademark? — Official USPTO explanation of trademark fundamentals, directly relevant to rights holders pursuing claims against vendors using protected character marks.
- 15 U.S.C. § 1114 – Trademark Infringement — The core federal statute establishing liability for unauthorized use of registered trademarks, central to claims against commercial cosplay vendors.
- U.S. Copyright Office: Fair Use Index — Authoritative resource on the fair use doctrine, which is commonly invoked as a defense by cosplay vendors and must be understood by rights holders.
- WIPO: Copyright in Character Merchandising — WIPO's analysis of intellectual property protections in character merchandising, providing an international authoritative perspective on the article's core topic.
- FTC Guidance on Selling Licensed Products — Official FTC guidance relevant to commercial vendors and licensing obligations, supporting the article's focus on monetized convention sales.